
Identifying Property Encroachments via the Title Commitment
In New York City real estate, the transition from a signed contract to a closed deed often stalls at the "Schedule B" exceptions. A title commitment is not a guarantee of a clean plot, but a document from a title insurance company that lists all conditions that must be met before they will issue a title insurance policy, according to apexsurvey.us. When a land surveyor identifies a fence three inches over a lot line or a neighbor’s retaining wall leaning into a yard, these physical realities transform from minor nuances into legal encumbrances that can halt a transaction.
This guide explains how to cross-reference a title commitment with a physical map to identify risks before they become liabilities. It is designed for developers, attorneys, and property owners navigating the dense urban landscape, where every inch of a boundary carries significant financial weight.
Why Survey Exceptions Derail NYC Transactions
The primary friction point in a property transfer is the gap between what is recorded in the county clerk’s office and what exists on the ground. A title search may show a clear chain of ownership, but only a field survey reveals how that ownership is physically compromised.
- Unrecorded easements for shared driveways or utility lines may not appear in public records but are obvious during a physical inspection.
- Structural encroachments like cornices, bay windows, or fire escapes may overhang property lines, requiring coordination between the surveyor and title company to identify the extent of the intrusion.
- Adverse possession claims can be triggered by long-standing fences that do not align with the legal description of the property.
- Issues found on a survey, such as improvements crossing property lines, may lead a title insurer to list them as exceptions that will not be covered by the policy.
The Playbook for Analyzing Survey Exceptions
1Locate Schedule B, Section II
This section of the title commitment is the most critical for identifying physical risks. It lists "Exceptions," which are items the title company will not cover, as noted by clglawaz.com. If this section includes a general "survey exception," the insurer is refusing to cover any issues that a boundary survey would have revealed.
2Compare the Metes and Bounds
The written legal description in the title commitment should match the descriptions, both written and depicted, on the survey exactly, according to law.du.edu. In NYC, these descriptions often use "metes and bounds," which describe the boundary via distances and angles from a fixed point. A discrepancy can indicate a "gap" or an "overlap" with an adjoining property, necessitating further investigation.
3Identify Physical Improvements on the Map
A Title & Property Survey displays man-made structures in relation to the property lines. Review the map for bold or dashed lines that represent fences, walls, or sheds. If these lines sit outside the solid boundary line, they are encroachments. According to clglawaz.com, minor encroachments of a few inches are common and often documented in this process.
4Review Recorded Easements Against Field Data
Easements are legal rights for others to use a portion of the land, such as for utility maintenance or shared access. The title commitment will list these exceptions, and an ALTA Survey is designed to work alongside the commitment to identify easements, encroachments, and improvements. The surveyor plots these items on the map to show how they affect the property.
The Impact of Survey Issues on Title
When a survey shows a significant encroachment, such as a building wall crossing the line, the title company may list the item as an exception under Schedule B-II. This means the title policy will not cover that specific issue. In many cases, this forces the parties involved to resolve the discrepancy, such as through an easement agreement or a boundary line affidavit, before a lender will proceed with funding the loan.
How Land Surveyors of NYC helps
Navigating these complexities requires a surveyor who understands the high-density constraints of New York City. The process involves a field visit to locate physical improvements, followed by a drafting process that overlays those findings against the recorded deed. When ordering a survey, property owners should provide the current title commitment to ensure the surveyor can specifically address the exceptions listed by the underwriter. For professional assistance with boundary identification or clearing title exceptions, call (315) 981-8556 or request a quote at https://landsurveyorsofnyc.com/.
Frequently asked questions
What happens if the survey shows a fence is two inches over the line?
Minor encroachments are common in residential transactions. The title commitment will usually list this as an exception until the surveyor provides a certified map showing the exact location. Depending on the lender's requirements, parties may need to seek an endorsement or a boundary agreement to address the encroachment.
How do "visual representations" differ from the legal description?
The legal description is a text-based definition of the land's perimeter (Schedule A), while the visual representation is the scaled map produced by the surveyor. According to law.du.edu, these must match exactly to ensure the property described is the same as the property surveyed.
Can I close if the title commitment has a general survey exception?
Most lenders will not allow a closing to proceed with a general survey exception. This exception means the insurance company is not liable for anything a survey would have shown, such as an encroachment or an easement. To remove this, a certified survey must be provided to the title company, which will then replace the general exception with "specific" exceptions for any issues found.
What is the difference between an encroachment and an easement?
An encroachment is a physical intrusion, like a neighbor’s structure crossing onto the land. An easement is a legal, recorded right for someone else to use the land for a specific purpose, such as a utility company running a sewer line. Both are identified during the title and survey review process and listed as exceptions if they affect the property.
Why does the surveyor need the title report before starting work?
The title report contains the legal description and the list of recorded easements (Schedule B) that the surveyor is required to locate and map. Providing this document ensures that the final map directly addresses the recorded encumbrances and the specific concerns of the title underwriter and the lender.
What happens when you get in touch: the situation is described, the specific questions that change the answer are asked, and a clear scope and next step is provided — no obligation.